"
From Fanfare: The Magazine for Serious Record Collectors
Review by Raymond Tuttle, July/August 2004
Volume 27, Number 6
Guitar quartets are not too unusual on CD, so it is lucky for the
Santa Fe Guitar Quartet (or “SFG4”) that they have recorded one that
stands out from the crowd. Journeys is eclectic but never silly or
self-indulgent, contradicting the feeling one sometimes gets that one
guitar recital is as good as another.
Mariano Fontana and Miguel Piva are from Argentina. Christopher Dorsey
and Eric Slavin are North Americans. Together, “SFG4” has played
throughout the Americas, and so it is fitting that the music on
Journeys represents both continents, with a little Albéniz and Bach
thrown in. The program has been constructed to reflect a variety of
musical styles and moods. The arrangements are by the musicians
themselves. (It appears that Will Ayton’s piece is the exception, as
it was written for guitar quartet.)
In this same issue, I gently berated a classical accordionist for
appropriating Astor Piazzolla’s music. Logic dictates that I should
go ballistic over a four-guitar arrangement of the same, but SFG4’s
comfort with the idiom disarms criticism. The Metheny, Albéniz,
and Guastavino works also sound as if they were written for the
ensemble. Carlos Guastavino’s infectious Baile (Dance) is one of those
“oh yeah, I’ve heard this before but never knew what it was” pieces,
and is tremendously enjoyable as such. I’m a little less convinced by
the Copland. Four guitars can’t duplicate the high-spirited racket of
the “Hoe Down,” although the “Saturday Night Waltz” is lovely. The
Bach is nicely romanticized a la Christopher Parkening, and it was
clever to follow it with Will Ayton’s work, written under the
influence of Villa-Lobos, who in turn wrote so much under the
influence of Bach.
In terms of engineering, this might be the best sounding guitar CD
I’ve ever encountered. I have no reason to think that SFG4 doesn’t
play this warmly and transparently in person, but a recording as good
as this certainly doesn’t hurt.
It takes a lot for one or more guitarists to impress me. Nevertheless,
impressed I am with Journeys , and greatly. Even if you don’t normally
consider a guitar recital, let this one be an exception.
|